Activity Feed › Discussion Forums › GNSS & Geodesy › BRX7 vs. S900A vs. S631
BRX7 vs. S900A vs. S631
Posted by plumb-bill on October 6, 2020 at 6:01 pmJust curious, what are the price differences if anyone knows?
Not that it really matters, it just seems that enough people are drawn to the Stonex and Hemisphere options that it must be a good amount?
timd1971 replied 2 weeks ago 12 Members · 16 Replies- 16 Replies
the brx7 is $3000 higher than the S631 Carlson has a put block on using their SurvCE for nonCarlson sponsored units i know nothing about stonex sorry
$3,000 per unit or per pair? That’s a pretty substantial difference either way…
I’m about to sign for a set or StoneX S900A w/DC. I’ll have to learn Survey Genius but it seems intuitive enough. I currently use the BRx7. They are incredible at quickly fixing in very difficult conditions. I had the same results trying out the S600A. They are all three the same GPS board with different dresses. I will get the full RTK setup with accessories and UT20 collector with FG for $15k.
Stonex often advertises its prices on its dealer websites.
ChidaPolaris.com and Measur.ca have Canadian prices.
- Posted by: @goodgps
Carlson has a put block on using their SurvCE for nonCarlson sponsored units
This is news to me, though 7 months after it was posted. Almost all my equipment is a non Carlson brand and it has all worked fine with SurvCE 5 through the latest version of SurvCE 6.
@bushaxe Just the new wave of low cost GNSS Rovers, Or at least that how I understood it. I tried to add one to my existing Surveyor2. I inferred that it was too much of a headache with getting the little things to work and the incessant whine of surveyors on the support line. And I can say that because I am one of them. The new wave of cheap GNSS is cheap for a reason.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but Carlson would still sell the previous versions of SurvCE, so if something has been dropped from a later version, one can still buy a previous version that has it on. Case in point – electronic bubble for Trimble 5600 instruments was introduced in V5 but dropped in later versions.
I believe this is still the case. We run SurvCE 5 for our 5600/S320 setups and SurvPC 6 for our BRX7/CR5+ setups. Our dealer always asks us what version we want to buy so I infer from that it is still possible to get 5. YMMV.
Any word on SurvCE going Android (and should I be trademarking the name “SurvAN”)?
I just purchased the iGage (stonex) receivers and they are solid, 10k out the door. You load software to your phone and run. The hardware is well built, radio link always solid, but I am having issues with reliable fixes in woods. I am currently going through settings to make sure I have everything set up correctly. But point spreads in wood cover are ‘fixed’ but have point spreads 5-10 feet off. Still breaking out gun for peace of mind and accuracy.
I have asked Jim Reinbold (our Carlson dealer) that question many, many times. Maybe @ladd-nelson could chime in?
Hemisphere is the OEM manufacturer for both the Carlson BRx7 and Stonex S900A. All three use the Hemisphere Phantom 40 board. Carlson takes the Hemisphere units and rebrands them as their own, for instance: BRx6 = S321 and BRx5 = S320 and the BRx7 = S631. Hardware wise they are identical. After version 6, the Hemisphere equipment is software locked form being used in SurvCE and PC. The annoying thing is, they only did this for North America, anywhere else in the world they work just fine. (Hemisphere is not the only brand they did this to, pretty much anything less expensive then the BRx7 has had this happen to them, but only in North America).
Stonex no longer uses the Hemisphere boards, as they have are still under the Unistrong umbrella, where as Hemisphere is now partnered with Case New Holland. Let me know if you have more questions about the Hemisphere gear.
- This reply was modified 2 weeks ago by bm-nolan.
What data collection software is Hemisphere using now? Is it Android based?
Carlson screws around too much…. too much jerking around with what is supported and isn’t. That does NOT make anyone very happy. Such a cruddy interface too like SurveyPro’s.
Microsurvey FieldGenius (Windows) MUCH better anyways!
FieldGenius has a feature I always need with my Leica’s… TURN TO POINT in 3D space using laser pointer or not… not quite finding anything else that does this.
The only issue i found is Trimble removed support of their instruments way back when… so have to use a very old version if want to use Trimble. But if your using Trimble, you are more than likely using their Trimble software of course.
Log in to reply.